Played for both clubs:
Sid Oliver Sunderland 1890-92 Birmingham 1894-96
Ike Webb Birmingham 1897-1901 Sunderland 1904-06
Arthur Bonthron Sunderland 1907-08 Birmingham 1910-11
Thomas Daykin Sunderland 1904-09 Birmingham 1908-12
Joe Lane Sunderland 1913-14 Birmingham 1919-22
Billy Ellis Sunderland 1919-28 Birmingham 1927-29
Jack Coxford Sunderland 1924-27 Birmingham 1927-30
Joe Devine Sunderland 1930-33 Birmingham 1934-37
Ted Purdon Birmingham 1951-54 Sunderland 1953-57
Harry Hooper Birmingham 1957-61 Sunderland 1960-63
Mike Hellawell Birmingham 1957-65 Sunderland 1964-67
Jim Montgomery Sunderland 1961-77 Birmingham 1976-79
Tony Towers Sunderland 1973-77 Birmingham 1977-80
Keith Bertschin Birmingham 1977-81 Sunderland 1986-88
Colin Todd Sunderland 1966-71 Birmingham 1979-82
Frank Worthington Birmingham 1979-82 Sunderland 1982-83
Tony Coton Birmingham 1980-85 Sunderland 1996-97
Mick Harford Birmingham 1981-85 Sunderland 1992-93
Howard Gayle Birmingham 1982-84 Sunderland 1984-86
Mark Prudhoe Sunderland 1982-83 Birmingham 1984-85
Jim McDonagh Birmingham 1984-85 Sunderland 1985-86
Ian Atkins Sunderland 1982-84 Birmingham 1987-90/91-92
Ian Rodgerson Birmingham 1990-93 Sunderland 1993-95
Tim Carter Sunderland 1987-92 Birmingham 1991-92
Paul Williams Sunderland 1994-95 Birmingham 1994-95
John Cornforth Sunderland 1984-91 Birmingham 1995-96
Gary Breen Birmingham 1995-97 Sunderland 2003-06
Marco Gabbiadini Sunderland 1987-92 Birmingham 1996-97
Terry Cooke Sunderland 1995-96 Birmingham 1996-97
Thomas Myhre Birmingham 1999-2000 Sunderland 2002-06
Allan Johnston Sunderland 1996-99 Birmingham 1999-2000Kenny Cunningham Birmingham 2002-06 Sunderland 2006-present