Rate The Ref v Man City - Phil Dowd

Last updated : 25 August 2004 By Kwacky

The mid-week man in the middle - Phil Dowd

The FA have made it clear that players need to clean up their act. Swift
punishment is handed out to those who fall foul of the rules. This is good
news for both players and fans alike.The only problem is that the appointed
Sheriffs of the beautiful game have the badge not always the respect needed
to impose themselves on a game.

Saturday's ref showed that you don't have to wave a coloured card to impose
authority. Dowd attempted to do the same but failed. Miserably. Mills soon
realised he had a licence to shove, push, grapple and late tackle and there
wasn't a thing Dowd was going to do about it. Word quickly spread amongst
the Manchester back 4 and this was acutely highlighted when Distin tried to
floor Heskey as he went up for the only goal of the game.

Mills was finally booked for a calculated tackle on Forssell which appeared
to be an aimed placing of Mills' boot on Forssell's achilles heel. The ref
produced a yellow and the Finn hobbled for the next 5 minutes and failed to
fully shake off the effects for the rest of the game.

At this point Dowd realised he had a job too. Unfortunately that meant that
free kicks were called when advantage was more, erm, advantageous.

The only other booking was for Izzet for a tackle that Mills and Co had
carried out all night without punishment.

Ref Rating - 6/10

Bookings: Mills (unsporting behaviour), Izzet (unsporting behaviour)


Birmingham C.1 Man City0
Heskey 8
Starting line-upSub'd
Taylor, Mai
Gray
Cunningham
Upson
Melchiot
Izzet
Gronkjaer
Lazaridis1 (59)
Johnson
Heskey2 (54)
Forssell3 (79)
SubstitutesSub'd
Clemence1 (59)
Tebily3 (79)
John2 (54)
Bennett
Taylor, Mar
Competition
Barclays Premiership
Tuesday 24th August 2004
Match Statistics
6Goal Attempts4
2On target1
4Off target3
0Woodwork0
2Corners5
20Fouls14
0Offside4
Cards shown
Mills (31)unsporting behaviour
Izzet (69)unsporting behaviour
Referee
Dowd, P
Staffordshire
Attendance
28551
Starting line-upSub'd
James
Jihai
Mills
Thatcher
Distin
Reyna
Sibierski1 (57)
Bosvelt2 (79)
Anelka
Wright-Phillips
Fowler3 (79)
SubstitutesSub'd
Macken3 (79)
Barton2 (79)
Sinclair1 (57)
Stuhr-Ellegaard
Bischoff